Atlantic Bay Resort, Key Largo

Atlantic Bay Resort - A waterfront retreat with private beach access, heated pool, and family-friendly amenities

Atlantic Bay Resort is a 3-star waterfront property on Tavernier Key, featuring 19 cottages and suites with views of Florida Bay or the pool area. Each accommodation includes fully equipped kitchenettes, premium bedding, and private tiki hut porches. Guests can access the resort’s private beach, heated and chilled swimming pool with a wheelchair lift, and complimentary amenities like kayaks, bicycles, and paddleboards. The Café offers indoor and outdoor dining with live entertainment, while Morada Bay provides Mediterranean-style beachfront meals. Nearby attractions include Florida Keys Wild Bird Center (2 miles), Indian Key Historic State Park, and Harry Harris Park. The resort also offers boat docking facilities and event packages for weddings and family reunions.

Pros

Private beach with waterfront tiki huts and complimentary water sports equipment.

Heated and chilled pool with wheelchair accessibility.

Fully equipped kitchenettes in all accommodations.

Proximity to marine attractions like Theater of the Sea and Florida Keys Wild Bird Center.

Cons

Some ground-level units lack private decks due to the two-story building layout.

Limited dining options within walking distance; Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory and Dairy Queen are the closest at 0.5 miles and 0.5 miles, respectively.