Sunset Beach, Shelter Island Heights

Sunset Beach - A pet-friendly 4-star seaside hotel with private beach access, French cuisine, and wellness services

Sunset Beach offers modern rooms with hardwood floors, glass-topped tables, flat-screen LCD TVs, iPod docking stations, and DVD players. The pet-friendly property provides grooming services and features a private beach where guests can spend the day. Free bicycle rentals allow exploration of Shelter Island, while yoga sessions and in-room massages are available for relaxation. Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar serves French cuisine in a casual atmosphere, accompanied by a full-service bar and curated wine list. Nearby landmarks include the East End Seaport Maritime Museum (2 miles) and Sylvester Manor Educational Farm (1.5 miles). Ferry service to Shelter Island is accessible from Greenport and Sag Harbor. Check-in begins at 4pm, and check-out is at 11am. Cribs and rollaway beds are available upon request.

Pros

Private beach access with complimentary bicycle rentals for island exploration.

Pet-friendly accommodations with on-site grooming services.

French cuisine and an extensive wine list at Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar.

Modern rooms feature iPod docking stations, flat-screen TVs, and hardwood floors.

Yoga sessions and in-room massages available for guests.

Cons

Check-in time is at 4pm, which may be later than some guests prefer.

The nearest major airport, Long Island MacArthur, is 52.5 miles away.